Luis Matos’ nomination to become a Rhode Island Supreme Court justice appears to be on a smooth path after he received unanimous support Tuesday from the House Judiciary Committee.
Matos’ nomination has been in the spotlight since last month, when a woman who Matos dated in the ‘90s wrote to legislators and said he had expressed anti-abortion views when she became pregnant.
On Tuesday, a procession of state and federal judges described Matos, currently a Superior Court judge, in glowing terms, citing his temperament and combination of judicial and prosecutorial experience.
“Justice Matos has demonstrated an intellectual honesty throughout his judicial career, as evidenced by the support of virtually every Superior Court justice and magistrate, as well as the federal judiciary of Rhode Island,” said Paul Suttell, chief justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court.
Suttell said after he created a committee on racial and ethnic fairness in the courts following the murder of George Floyd, Matos became an invaluable member, “displaying a resolute commitment to the principles of equal justice for all persons.” Suttell said Matos also played a key role in lowering court costs for defendants.
Rhode Island Supreme Court Justice Melissa Long praised Matos for his understanding of the law, a respectful temperament and impartiality.
U.S. District Court Judge John J. “Jack” McConnell Jr., said, “We all have deep respect for Judge Matos’ judgment, integrity, intellect, judicial temperament and unwavering commitment to the fair and impartial administration of justice, ensuring equal access to justice for all.”
During his own appearance before the Judiciary Committee, Matos emphasized his biography, particularly how he was able to overcome the difficult circumstances of his parents’ childhood in Portugal after the family moved to the Fox Point section of Providence when he was five.
He credited a bilingual language program at the neighborhood elementary school, now known as Vartan Gregorian Elementary, with putting him on the path to achieve the American dream.
Within six years of coming to Rhode Island, his parents were able to buy a two-decker in Cranston – something that Matos said current newcomers can’t do due to the cost of housing.
The judge said he keeps in mind how not everyone has the supportive network of family and neighbors that he had growing up.
“That is not the case for many of those that I see in the courtroom on a regular basis,” Matos said. “I work hard every day to remember that and to decide cases well, but with empathy and full recognition of everyone’s circumstances.”
Matos wound up graduating from Brown University and the law school at the University of Connecticut. He worked as a federal prosecutor in Delaware, Washington, D.C., and Rhode Island before Gov. Lincoln Chafee nominated him for Superior Court in 2012.
Gov. Dan McKee nominated Matos to fill a vacancy created by the retirement earlier this year of Maureen McKenna Goldberg, who was among those on hand for the Judiciary Committee hearing.
Matos met privately with lawmakers in recent weeks.
Under questioning by Judiciary Chair Carol McEntee (D-Narragansett), Matos reiterated his support for a woman’s right to choose an abortion. He said he’s held that view for a long time, although he once saw the issue differently.
That became an issue after a woman who dated Matos in Washington, D.C., in the early 1990s wrote to lawmakers, expressing concern that Matos was personally opposed to abortion, she said, but urged her to get an abortion when she became pregnant.
Judiciary Committee members tried drawing Matos out on other issues of the day, including automated license plate readers, how state lawmakers changed the statute of limitations for cases of clergy abuse, and a pending U.S. Supreme Court case involving the right of states to regulate AR-15s and similar guns.
Matos declined to engage with the gist of these questions.
“I’ve always endeavored to not let my opinions, whatever they might be, be the focus of any kind of public discussion because A) I think it’s important to maintain that kind of distinction,” he said. “It’s also important to the extent that matters may come before me, may not come before me, that I haven’t pre-decided anything.”
Matos’ nomination is slated to move to the full House of Representatives on Dec. 1. The Senate Judiciary Committee is slated to take up his nomination on Nov. 30.